Calling a meme

Mt Etna

As a matter of fact, no one knows whether this meme graphic is correct or not. The specific eruption was not named or dated, and, in any event, humans have been around for only a few of Etna’s major eruptions during its past 500,000 years or more of eruptions.

A frequent response to this graphic meme is another meme popular among global warming proponents but one which is easily refuted:

“The projected 2010 anthropogenic CO2 emission rate of 35 gigatons per year is 135 times greater than the 0.26-gigaton- per-year preferred estimate for volcanoes.”

Gerlach’s meme quoted immediately above (i.e. Gerlach’s calculation based on a very small set of volcanoes) has been been thoroughly debunked in the scientific literature. But, for the sake of argument, let me illustrate the futility of his and AGW’s argument.

Let’s assume that Gerlach’s calculation is correct and other literature references are correct that claim that Etna produces 10% of the total annual CO2 emitted from volcanoes. Then, just for purposes of this illustration, Etna produces 0.026 gigatons CO2 per year (i.e. 10% of the total volcanic CO2 annual emissions) and humans produce 35 gigatons per year. Mt Etna has been producing this amount of CO2 for about 500,000 years, not including any major Etna eruptions, based on Etna’s passive emissions as measured today.  Using Gerlach’s calculation, humans produce 35 gigatons of CO2 per year, and let’s says humans have been doing that since the beginning of the industrial revolution, i.e. for 200 years, which is a huge over-estimation.

In summary, for this quick estimate, humans have produced 7,000 gigatons of CO2 and Mt Etna has produced 13,000 gigatons of CO2. But, Mt Etna is only one of thousands of CO2-emitting volcanoes and there are many other rifts and tectonic boundaries which have been pumping gigatons of CO2 into the oceans and atmosphere for thousands of years before humans (as far as we know) existed. The meme in the Mt Etna graphic is making a valid point: human CO2 is insignificant with regard to the climate of this planet.

For more detail and background, see:



About budbromley

Bud is a retired life sciences executive. Bud's entrepreneurial leadership exceeded three decades. He was the senior business development, marketing and sales executive at four public corporations, each company a supplier of analytical and life sciences instrumentation, software, consumables and service. Prior to those positions, his 19 year career in Hewlett-Packard Company's Analytical Products Group included worldwide sales and marketing responsibility for Bioscience Products, Global Accounts and the International Olympic Committee, as well as international management assignments based in Japan and Latin America. Bud has visited and worked in more than 65 countries and lived and worked in 3 countries.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Calling a meme

  1. IF you can look better in that ”smog mushroom” you’ll notice that: 95% of that smog is water vapor / H2O; water accumulated deep down for the time the volcano was a sleep, now under tremendous heat is accompanying UP other gases and silica; beautiful set up. Also is used by the phony skeptics to promote that CO2 is a global warming gas… Warmist love them for that and should give them the biggest medals


    • budbromley says:

      Stefan, we call it vog. Vog does indeed contain a lot of water.


      • Warmit know about that smog – and the terrible smog from cooling the towers – please don’t underestimate the enemy, they are professional manipulators. #2: when you guys say in your comments as above – Warmist show your comments to the media and explain that is mostly water; whom you think media will follow and whom will ignore in future? ONLY REAL TRUTH IS WARMIST ACHILLES HILL!


Leave a Reply to stefanthedenier Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.